If you’ve been reading and remembering (I can’t blame you if you haven’t been doing either…), you’ll remember me complaining musing early on that I thought the only way to get plastic free milk was if I bought a cow.
I had a friend in Ohio tell me via Facebook that at their grocery store, they can buy milk in glass jars from an Ohio-based dairy, Hartzler Farms. When you’re done with them, you return them to the store and Hartzler reuses them. I was so jealous and lamented that I wished we had that in my area!
….But apparently, I just needed to open my freakin’ eyes….
I sent my husband to the grocery store and he texted me this picture of Hartzler milk in glass jars in the grocery store 5 minutes from my house. WE NEVER KNEW! Or rather, we never paid attention.

If this milk isn’t a symbol of this zero waste journey for me, I don’t know what is.
I am realizing that I have just never paid attention to the things I have been using. And I’m so thankful to those who have already taken this on and posted about it because they are helping me to open my eyes.
Anyhow, if you are paying close attention (teacher kudos!), you’ll have noticed the price tag on these sweet babies – $5 a pop in comparison to the $2 on milk in a single-use plastic jug. Yeah….not exactly what this cheapskate likes to think about.
Keeping in mind, when you bring the glass milk jugs back to the grocery store (the Giant Eagle service desk in our case), you get your $2 deposit for each glass jar back. In cash! But, you’re still paying $1 more for only half a gallon. Yikes.
…but let’s come back to that later….
On the Hartzler Dairy website, they explain in detail why many people with milk allergies or lactose intolerance can drink their milk. It’s non-homogenized which apparently means better nutrient delivery in your body. They Low-temperature Vat Pasteurize their milk so that it’s safe according to the US Food and Drug Administration, but it doesn’t kill all the good stuff in addition to the bacteria. Also, as noted on their bottles, they don’t use chemical pesticides and herbicides on their farm.

Because of this, it tastes different.
I’m not a big milk drinker because it previously upset my stomach. I found the hormonal fluctuation of my pregnancies helped me to tolerate milk better now than I could during college and in my 20’s. I used to not eat cereal for many years because I didn’t want a stomachache, but when I was pregnant I was able to have cereal and ice cream again.
When my husband brought it home that night, after playing Christopher Columbus and “discovering” what was already there, I tried it.
I honestly don’t know how to describe the taste of it…it tastes like cow? No, that’s no good – I’ve never licked a cow to know for sure. It’s just…different. My mom was raised on a dairy farm (Hi, Mom!) and I need to get her over here to try it so she can tell me if it’s more “natural”.
When I tried it, I immediately had the crushing thought that my kids were going to hate it and refuse to drink it. Here, I find a PERFECT, nearby solution for milk in plastic jugs and my kids are going to hate the taste.
They haven’t noticed a difference. They still suck it down like crazy. Not a SINGLE word about it.
It’s just me and my husband who are kinda like…eh, we miss the taste of milk that we’ve grown up with. But, we’re getting old and set in our ways.
HOWEVER, we’ve discussed it and agreed that it’s better milk for our kids (have you read about the effects of growth hormones in milk?), it’s better for the environment, and I really like supporting a local dairy with these kinds of values – even if we’re paying a little more.
I think we agreed….did we agree? In my mind we agreed….

At the top of the milk is usually a cream plug that you can break apart, then shake up into the milk, or on their website they recommend putting it in coffee. I put some in my tea that I’m drinking right now. For the record, their milk in a cup of tea has no noticeable difference. I notice it when you drink it straight.
We’re on our 3rd round of the Hartzler milk “loop” and it’s been noticeable that our plastic recycling is much, much less without the plastic milk jugs in it. It was a HUGE reduction, probably because we don’t flatten out the plastic milk jugs when they were empty and those puppies were big.

The glass jugs do have plastic lids that so far I’ve returned with the glass bottles. There is also a pull-away-plastic-sealing-band-thing on them too, but I’m saving those in a jar to send off to Terracycle.
Now if only I could find cheese and chips in something not plastic. 🙂























